Robin Hood could bear any wind but a thaw wind: Difference between revisions

From International Robin Hood Bibliography
m (Text replacement - "=== Background ===" to "== Background ==")
mNo edit summary
 
(13 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
<p id="byline">By Henrik Thiil Nielsen, 2014-10-16. Revised by {{#realname:{{REVISIONUSER}}}}, {{REVISIONYEAR}}-{{REVISIONMONTH}}-{{REVISIONDAY2}}.</p>
__NOTOC__<div class="no-img"><p id="byline">By Henrik Thiil Nielsen, 2014-10-16. Revised by {{#realname:{{REVISIONUSER}}}}, {{REVISIONYEAR}}-{{REVISIONMONTH}}-{{REVISIONDAY2}}.</p>
<div class="no-img">
The exact meaning of the expression ''Robin Hood could bear any wind but a thaw wind'', with variations such as "stand" for "bear", "anything" for "any wind", is uncertain, but I think it is testimony to the reality of the experience of wind chill.<ref>See [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_chill Wikipedia: Wind chill.] I know from experience that winter typically feels colder in windswept, open Denmark than in sheltered but colder areas of southern Norway.</ref> Uttering this expression would thus amount to an (implicit) assertion that a windy day with temperatures above feezing point can feel colder than a calm day with temperatures below 0C&deg;.
The exact meaning of the expression ''<section begin=proverb />Robin Hood could bear any wind but a thaw wind<section end=proverb />'', with variations such as "stand" for "bear", "anything" for "any wind", is uncertain, but I think it is testimony to the reality of the experience of wind chill.<ref>See [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_chill Wikipedia: Wind chill.] I know from experience that winter typically feels colder in windswept, open Denmark than in sheltered but colder areas of southern Norway.</ref> Uttering this expression would thus amount to an (implicit) assertion that a windy day with temperatures above feezing point can feel colder than a calm day with temperatures below 0C&deg;.


=== Collections and lists ===
== Collections and lists ==
* {{:Dobson, Richard Barrie 1976a}}, p. 290.
* {{:Dobson, Richard Barrie 1976a}}, p. 290.
* {{:Hermentrude 1865a}}, lists 25 proverbs, including "Robin Hood could bear any wind but a thaw wind".<ref>Hermentrude cites an 1864 Lancashire dialect text, reprinted in {{:Ormerod, Oliver 1901a}}, pp. 105-238, as his source of the majority of the proverbs. I have not found the Robin Hood proverb in Ormerod.</ref><!--
* {{:Hermentrude 1865a}}, lists 25 proverbs, including "Robin Hood could bear any wind but a thaw wind".<ref>Hermentrude cites an 1864 Lancashire dialect text, reprinted in {{:Ormerod, Oliver 1901a}}, pp. 105-238, as his source of the majority of the proverbs. I have not found the Robin Hood proverb in Ormerod.</ref>


=== Citations ===
<div class="century">{{#ask:[[Category:proverb-thaw]]|format=embedded|embedformat=h3|limit=1000|sort=Utitle|intro=<h2>Citations</h2><div class="mw-collapsible mw-collapsed allusions" data-expandtext="Show citations" data-collapsetext="Hide citations">|outro=</div>}}</div>
<div class="century">{{#ask:[[Category:proverb-thaw]]| format=embedded|embedformat=h4|columns=1|limit=1000|sort=Utitle}}-->


=== Brief mention ===
== Discussion ==
* {{:Bowes, Arthur 1922a}}
* {{:D, M 1873a}}
* {{:Fishwick, Henry 1873a}}
* {{:Holland, Robert 1873a}}
* {{:Self-Weeks, William 1922a}}.
 
== Brief mention ==
* {{:Gilchrist, Robert Murray 1913a}}, p. 24.
* {{:Gilchrist, Robert Murray 1913a}}, p. 24.
* {{:Turner, Joseph Horsfall 1893a}}, p. 203, cites a few Robin Hood proverbs, including this 'As I shiver whilst writing these lines, I remember the force of the Brighouse saying, "Robin Hood feared nought but a thaw wind."'
* {{:Turner, Joseph Horsfall 1893a}}, p. 203, cites a few Robin Hood proverbs, including this 'As I shiver whilst writing these lines, I remember the force of the Brighouse saying, "Robin Hood feared nought but a thaw wind."'
Line 16: Line 21:
== Background ==
== Background ==
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_chill Wikipedia: Wind chill.]
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_chill Wikipedia: Wind chill.]
=== Notes ===
== Notes ==
<references/>
<references/>




</div>
</div>
<div id="dplcatlinks" class="subcategory"><div id="dplcatarea">
 
{{#ask: [[Category:Proverb]][[Utitle::<<{{#replace:{{uc:{{PAGENAME}}}}|&#39;|'}}]]|order=descending|searchlabel=|format=template|introtemplate=BeforeNav|template=Nav|outrotemplate=Previous|link=none|limit=1|sort=Utitle}}[[Proverbs]]{{#ask: [[Category:Proverb]][[Utitle::>>{{#replace:{{uc:{{PAGENAME}}}}|&#39;|'}}]]|order=ascending|searchlabel=|format=template|introtemplate=BeforeNav|template=Nav|outrotemplate=Next|link=none|limit=1|sort=Utitle}}</div></div>
 
[[Category:Proverbs]]
{{ProverbNavigation}}
[[Category:Proverb]]
[[Category:Proverbs-topics]]
{{#set:Utitle={{#replace:{{uc:{{PAGENAME}}}}|&#39;|'}}}}
{{#set:Proverb==Robin Hood could bear any wind but a thaw wind}}

Latest revision as of 06:30, 12 March 2021

By Henrik Thiil Nielsen, 2014-10-16. Revised by Henrik Thiil Nielsen, 2021-03-12.

The exact meaning of the expression Robin Hood could bear any wind but a thaw wind, with variations such as "stand" for "bear", "anything" for "any wind", is uncertain, but I think it is testimony to the reality of the experience of wind chill.[1] Uttering this expression would thus amount to an (implicit) assertion that a windy day with temperatures above feezing point can feel colder than a calm day with temperatures below 0C°.

Collections and lists

Citations

1831 - Roby, John - Traditions of Lancashire, Second Series (4)

"How long run we on through these great blubbering waves, ere we end our voyage? This night wind is worse than a Robin Hood's thaw."[3]

Discussion

Brief mention

Background

Notes

  1. See Wikipedia: Wind chill. I know from experience that winter typically feels colder in windswept, open Denmark than in sheltered but colder areas of southern Norway.
  2. Hermentrude cites an 1864 Lancashire dialect text, reprinted in Ormerod, Oliver; March, Henry Colley. The writings of Oliver Ormerod (Rochdale, 1901), pp. 105-238, as his source of the majority of the proverbs. I have not found the Robin Hood proverb in Ormerod.
  3. Roby, John. Traditions of Lancashire. Second Series (London, 1831), vol. II, p. 251.